Is the Clementine Bag the Best $210 You’ll Ever Spend?
|
Time to read: 8 min
In today's post, we're diving into the Clementine bag from The Horse, an Australian brand that has garnered attention for its modern, sophisticated designs. You’ve been asking me to review it, and today I’m going to break it down, examining it through the five key pillars that make a great bag. Let’s take a closer look at whether this $210 bag is worth your investment.
In this blog, we will answer the following questions:
- What makes the Clementine bag’s design stand out among other leather bags in its price range?
- How does the craftsmanship and engineering of the Clementine bag ensure durability and long-term value?
- Does the Clementine bag’s affordable 3x markup offer better value compared to other designer bags?
DISCLAIMER: This is an UNSPONSORED review. I purchased all of these products myself and am not affiliated with the brand mentioned in any way. All statements and expressions made about the products are solely the opinion of Tanner Leatherstein and are not meant to be conclusive or definitive. The purpose of this video is for informational and educational purposes only. We recommend that as a consumer, you exercise your due diligence and research on the products before adopting the opinion of Tanner Leatherstein.
Design: A Refreshing Silhouette
When it comes to design, the Clementine bag immediately catches your eye. While it isn’t entirely unique in terms of concept, its curvaceous, semi-structured form sets it apart from others. The way the bag curves creates a distinctive silhouette that stands out without being overly eccentric. The flexibility of the design adds a dynamic quality to the bag that allows it to hold its shape while still offering a slouchy, relaxed feel. This balance of structure and fluidity is masterfully executed, making the Clementine a refreshing design choice. I’d give the design a solid 4 out of 5 for its unique yet accessible aesthetic.
Structure: Ingeniously Built Support
Opening up the Clementine bag, I’m immediately impressed with its internal engineering. The structure is sophisticated, with layers of reinforcement on the sides that help the bag maintain its form. The clever use of non-stretch fabrics on the interior ensures that the leather is supported without losing its soft, slouchy shape. This dual-layered structure strikes a perfect balance between a rigid and flexible build, ensuring the bag keeps its integrity over time. The craftsmanship here is top-notch, deserving a 4.5 out of 5 for its thoughtful and well-executed internal support.
Craftsmanship: Impeccably Clean
Moving on to the craftsmanship, I find the overall construction of the Clementine bag to be clean and precise. The stitching is flawless, with no visible defects inside or out. I couldn't find a label indicating the country of origin, but given the quality and complexity of the bag, I’m led to believe it’s made in China. Bags of this caliber, with such clean craftsmanship, typically come from China, where production costs are more competitive. Despite this, the quality control seems excellent. I’d rate the craftsmanship at 4 out of 5—well-made and nearly flawless in execution.
Hardware: A Mediocre Touch
When it comes to hardware, the Clementine bag is a bit underwhelming. It features a hook, a D-ring, and a stud, which while functional, don't add much in terms of luxury or visual appeal. The thin lacquer layer on the hardware feels a bit fragile, and the overall finish seems somewhat mediocre, especially when compared to the rest of the bag's quality. While it's not a dealbreaker, I’d say the hardware falls into the lower end of the market. Considering the price point, I expected this level of quality. For the hardware, I’d give it a 3 out of 5.
Leather: Beautiful and Rich
One of the standout features of the Clementine bag is its leather. The grain is embossed with a subtle pebble texture that retains the beauty of natural leather while adding durability. When I applied acetone to remove the finish, I was impressed by how much of the natural grain was still visible. The leather feels rich to the touch, offering that wonderful chaotic pattern of grain that leather enthusiasts love. This is a well-chosen material that brings out the best in both function and aesthetics. For the leather, I’d rate it a 4 out of 5—it’s a strong, impressive choice for the price.
Value for Money: A Great Deal
Now, let’s talk about the value for money. Based on my estimates, it costs around $75 to make a bag of this quality. The leather, which makes up about seven square feet of the bag, would cost approximately $20. Add in the cost of hardware and labor, and the total production cost comes to about $47. Given that the Clementine bag is priced at $210, this results in a markup of less than 3x. While this is a bit risky for a newer brand trying to grow, it translates to excellent value for the customer. In my opinion, this bag offers one of the best values of the year in terms of both design and quality.
| Criteria | Score | Results |
| Leather | 4 | Good leathers for the application in hand. Coming from environmentally-conscious tanneries. |
| Hardware | 3 | Alloy hardware with acceptable coating. Lifetime may be impacted due to the coating of the hardware. |
| Design | 4 | A creative take on a classical design concept. |
| Engineering | 4.5 | Clean and quality inner support materials and structure. |
| Craftsmanship | 4 | Perfect machine-stitching with excellent edge finishing. Immaculate inside and out, with no visible flaws, showing a commitment to quality. |
| OVERALL SCORE | 3.90 | Very good example of great quality for a great price without any risk to try. |
|
PRICE/COST MULTIPLIER |
3X | Exceptional value for money. |
Conclusion: Is It Worth It?
In conclusion, the Clementine bag from The Horse is an exceptional find at its price point. The design is refreshing, the structure is expertly engineered, and the craftsmanship is clean and precise. While the hardware doesn’t impress, the leather and overall quality of the bag more than make up for it. At $210, this bag offers incredible value, especially considering its production cost and the quality it delivers.
So, is it worth your money? Absolutely. If you're looking for a well-designed, well-crafted leather bag at a reasonable price, the Clementine is an excellent choice. It stands out as one of the best values I’ve reviewed this year.
Let me know in the comments if you think the Clementine bag is worth it for your money. I'll see you next time, one dissection at a time.
Want to read more?
Frequently Asked Questions
How can I submit my product for the Leather Bureau of Investigation, and what happens after submission?
To submit your product, please complete this form. Once submitted, we'll review the details to determine if your product fits our project. If accepted, you'll receive an email within seven days. In return for your donation, we’ll send you a free product from our PEGAI catalog, and all information provided will be kept confidential. If not selected, you’re welcome to submit other products in the future.
This project is only for leather goods customers. If you're a brand, please refer to the Chopping Block / Rip My Bag Challenge FAQ.
How can I suggest a brand for review?
You can view all the brands currently on our list here: Brand List.
If the brand you want to see reviewed isn’t listed, simply leave your suggestion in the comments section! We’ll gather all suggestions and add them to the Suggestion Box in Tanner Leatherstein's website's Forum for voting, where the most requested brands have a chance to be featured next.
Does Tanner offer advisory services?
Yes! Tanner offers advisory services specializing in leather selection, manufacturing, and prototyping-related inquiries. The fee is $300 per hour.
The consultation process includes:
- A complimentary 30-minute initial call to understand your needs.
- A 30-minute follow-up call to review findings and gather feedback on your objectives.
- A final 30-minute call to present recommendations.
If you're interested, please let us know so we can send the scheduling links.
Is Tanner available for media interviews?
Yes, Tanner is open for media interviews! If you'd like to collaborate on a feature or interview him, please email him directly at tanner@pegai.com.
Whether it's about leather crafting, brand reviews, or the business side of PEGAI, Tanner is happy to share his insights and expertise.
How can my brand participate in the "Rip My Bag" Challenge / Chopping Block?
Here's a quick overview of the process:
- Product Selection: You provide a list of products; Tanner selects one for review.
- Anonymous Purchase: The product is bought anonymously to simulate a real customer experience.
- Independent Review: A review video is created and shared across social media platforms (excluding YouTube).
- No Prior Screening: You won't see the video before it’s posted, and no pre-approval is allowed.
- Reimbursement: After publishing, you’ll receive an invoice for the product cost.
- Video Fee: A $1,000 production fee covers review, filming, and editing costs. This is separate from the product reimbursement.
- Transparency: The video will be marked as "paid collaboration" to ensure honesty.
Watch the video disclaimer here. For more information, please email us at tanner@pegai.com.
IMPORTANT NOTICE:
At this time, participation is limited to brands based in the US and EU due to logistical challenges. If we expand to more countries, we’ll reach out to those interested. In the meantime, we’re happy to add your brand to our list for potential future reviews, though we can't guarantee a timeline. Thank you for your understanding!
NEXT STEPS:
If you're interested, please complete our Intake Survey and pay the video fee. We’ll confirm your slot within 48 hours.
About Tanner
Tanner Leatherstein
Known as the "butcher of leather bags," Tanner has amassed over 2 million followers and 301 million views, with features in outlets like The New York Times and Financial Times. PEGAI, Tanner's brand, embodies his passion for crafting premium leather goods with unmatched authenticity and precision.
