A Hawaiian Dream or a Rough Reality? Unpacking the RŌMFRĒ EDC Backpack
When RŌMFRĒ, a brand based in Hawaii—my absolute favorite place in the world—challenged me to rip their EDC backpack, I was intrigued. For $250, I got my hands on this bag, ready to dissect its materials, craftsmanship, and overall value.
DISCLAIMER : The “Rip My Bag Challenge” is a review series that tests leather products’ quality, price, and craftsmanship. While the brand supports the challenge financially, my opinions stay fair, unbiased, and truthful. Products featured are purchased anonymously without brand involvement. Brands have no control over content, publishing dates, or the review process. You may read the full disclaimer here.
What's Inside?
First Impressions: Packaging and Leather Quality
The backpack arrived in a simple cardboard box with a plastic bag inside. It was a bit squished, but nothing that couldn’t be fixed. As I pulled the bag out, the leather caught my eye—described as full-grain on the website, it looked distressed, which can be confusing to some. Full-grain leather typically refers to leather that has not been sanded or buffed, retaining its natural texture and markings. However, this leather had a distressed finish, likely achieved through a process involving infused waxes and some sanding. It's a nice, above-average crazy horse leather that gives the bag a rugged, worn-in look.
Craftsmanship: The Good, the Bad, and the Sloppy
Now, let's talk about craftsmanship. To be blunt, it's rough at best, reminiscent of the work I've seen from Mexican manufacturers. The stitching lines aren't clean, the inner lining is poorly cut, and the edge paint work is downright sloppy. In some places, they used edge paint to hide layers, but the execution was so poor that the paint went over the surface and wasn't cleaned up. This level of workmanship leaves much to be desired, especially when considering the price point.
One area where the bag shines, however, is in its fabric choices. The inner linings, padded inner surfaces of the straps, and overall fabric selections are top-notch. They feel durable and well-suited to the bag’s design. Unfortunately, the hardware doesn't live up to the same standard. The zippers, in particular, are problematic. The design forces the zippers to pop outwards at the corners, making them difficult to operate. This is a structural flaw that could have been avoided with better design and construction.
@tanner.leatherstein Distressed leather or just distressed craftsmanship? 🧐💼 Visit them at @romfre.travel.co. DISCLAIMER: The “Rip My Bag Challenge” is a review series that tests leather products’ quality, price, and craftsmanship. While the brand supports the challenge financially, my opinions stay fair, unbiased, and truthful. Products featured are purchased anonymously without brand involvement. Brands have no control over content, publishing dates, or the review process. You may watch the full disclaimer on my pinned video. #hawaii #leatherbackpack #bagreview #leathertok #leatherbrand #isitworthit #tannerleatherstein ♬ original sound - Tanner Leatherstein
The Inside Story: Materials and Durability
Opening the bag, I found an interesting mix of materials. The hidden spongy materials in the support pieces felt budget-friendly and cheap, but the lining fabrics were excellent—durable polyester that complements the design. However, the glue applications and stitching are clearly rushed, echoing the sloppy craftsmanship seen throughout the bag.
Color Transfer Concerns: Rub Test on Distressed Leather
As this backpack is made with distressed leather, the color transfer might be a concern for some users. Picture this: you're wearing a white fabric, and the leather rubs against your back repeatedly. This friction could lead to color transfer. In a dry rub test, there was a slight transfer of color, which isn't surprising given the nature of distressed leather.
To further assess its durability, I tested the leather with a bit of water, simulating a scenario where you're sweating while carrying the bag. This time, there was some color bleeding, but it wasn't excessive. In extreme cases, distressed leather can transfer a significant amount of color onto clothing, but in this instance, the transfer was within acceptable limits. This level of color transfer is typical for distressed leather without any protective finish, making it an expected but manageable issue for users.
A Deeper Look: Leather Analysis
Applying acetone to the leather revealed no dyes, confirming this as a typical crazy horse finish—infused oils and waxes on top of nubuck leather. Nubuck is slightly buffed grain, and while some might debate calling it full-grain, I don’t have an issue with it. The cross-section shows that the majority of the grain is still intact, and the leather feels substantial and well-tanned. It's a good leather choice for this style of bag, with an American feel that's nicely done.
Cost Breakdown: Is It Worth It?
Estimating the cost to make a bag like this in Mexico, including the leather, linings, and hardware, I arrived at around $122. Given the $250 price tag, that's a 2x multiplier—not a huge margin for a sustainable business but a good value for consumers.
Despite the imperfections, this bag offers above-average distressed leather and high-quality internal linings. The craftsmanship is average, with some rough edges, but for the price, it’s a great value. What stands out to me is the story behind the brand—a family living in the paradise that is Hawaii, managing an online brand and offering good value to the Leatherverse.
Final Thoughts: Inspiration from Hawaii
Hawaii has always been a source of inspiration for me, and this project is no exception. The idea of living in such a magical place while managing a brand was something I considered, but ultimately, I decided it wasn't for me—too far from everything. Yet, this family proved me wrong. They’re living in heaven and successfully offering a product that’s both affordable and well-made.
In the end, I’m happy with what I found in this RŌMFRĒ EDC backpack. It’s not perfect, but it’s a solid deal for the price, and I wish the brand continued success.
Leave a comment