When Premium Brands Fail Their Loyal Customers - Elena's Issue with Hermes
In the world of high fashion, a leather bag from a status symbol brand isn't just an accessory—it's a statement. When you invest thousands of dollars into a piece, you're not merely buying a product; you're buying into a legacy, a promise of quality, and an experience. But what happens when that promise is broken?
Imagine this: you've spent a big fortune on a leather bag from a prestigious brand. It's perfect in every way until something goes wrong. You reach out to the brand, expecting the superior treatment that aligns with the product's price tag. Instead, you're met with a response that wouldn't be out of place in a bargain basement store's customer service department. The question then isn't just, "What do you do?" but more critically, "What can you do?"
I regularly receive emails from frustrated customers who have been loyal to a brand, only to have their experience tarnished by a faulty product. These customers expect an apology, swift correction, and respectful treatment. Instead, they find themselves staring at a cold computer screen or listening to a monotonous voice on the phone, repeating a scripted response: "We are not responsible," or "We will get back to you once we consult with our supervisor."
It's astonishing how often this happens and how powerless these customers feel. Despite the brands' dominance in marketing and prestige, the aggrieved customer lacks an equal platform to voice their concerns, warn other potential buyers, and hold these brands accountable. This disparity inspired me to create a new video format called "Voice of Leatherverse," a platform where the true bosses of the leather market—the customers—can share their stories.
Voice of Leatherverse: A New Platform for the Customer’s Voice
The goal of Voice of Leatherverse isn't just to highlight the negative experiences but also to celebrate the positive ones. We aim to recognize brands and their team members who go above and beyond, creating exemplary experiences for their customers. If you've had an experience, good or bad, that you think others should hear about, reach out to me at tanner@pegai.com. I promise to read and respond to each inquiry, creating a space for your stories in the Leatherverse.
@tanner.leatherstein Paid $$$$ for a luxury leather bag and got a shocking response from the brand? 😲 Let’s talk about it! #storytime #review #fashiontiktok #customerstories #customerexperience #voiceofpeople #tannerleatherstein ♬ original sound - Tanner Leatherstein
A Tale from Hermes: Elena’s Unfortunate Journey
Let's delve into an example of the kind of stories Voice of Leatherverse aims to share. Meet Elena, a loyal customer of Hermes, a brand synonymous with luxury and exclusivity. Her journey with Hermes, however, is a testament to how even the most prestigious brands can falter in their customer service.
Elena's story began several months ago when she made her first purchase at an Hermes store in Stockholm—a puffer jacket priced at nearly $4,000. This initial purchase led to more, including two pairs of Bouncing Sneakers, three pairs of Santorini slippers, multiple Kelly belts, passport holders, bags including the Herbag, Evelyne, and the prized 24/24 bag, along with numerous charms, t-shirts, and cardigans. Elena's investment in Hermes was substantial, akin to the cost of an apartment in Spain.
The first issue arose with her prized 24/24 bag. Within two weeks, the stitches started to separate, and the leather showed signs of wear. Elena contacted Hermes' online customer service, sent them pictures, and was told to return the bag to the store for a replacement. The new bag arrived in March, but the problems were far from over.
In February, Elena purchased a pair of day sneakers that began to dye her feet black after just a few wears. Embarrassed and frustrated, she contacted the store and returned the sneakers, receiving a new pair in May. However, her troubles didn’t end there. On May 3rd, she picked up the new sneakers and bought a pair of loafers. The second time she wore the loafers, she lost a buckle, marking her third complaint in two months.
@tanner.leatherstein Is this how Hermes treats loyal customers? 😳 #storytime #hermes #hermesaddict #customerstories #voiceofpeople #tannerleatherstein ♬ original sound - Tanner Leatherstein
Confrontation at the Store
Angry and annoyed, Elena went to the Hermes store and handed the buckle to the manager, demanding an immediate resolution. The store’s sales manager, visibly uncomfortable in front of other customers, asked her to return on Monday to fix the issue. Elena insisted on resolving it then and there, but the manager couldn’t accommodate her. She returned home, changed shoes, and came back to the store, only to face a month of silence and unreturned messages.
Frustrated, Elena contacted the Hermes office in France, which promised to address her complaint. The next day, she received an email stating they couldn’t fix her loafers and offered either a new pair or a credit note. Hermes, it seemed, did not issue refunds.
Elena requested the same loafers. The store manager then intervened, insisting she deal only with him and forbidding her from contacting other sales associates. When Elena visited the store, he asserted his authority, stating his staff wasn’t obligated to reply to emails and threatening to ban her from the store if she continued to complain.
Resolution and Reflection
Despite the store manager’s threats, Hermes eventually refunded her money, a rare occurrence for the brand. Elena’s persistence paid off, but the experience left her feeling disillusioned.
"I thought at that moment maybe someone is filming me; it's a joke," Elena said, reflecting on the ordeal. She continued to contact both the French and Swedish offices, and eventually, the head of the Nordics region contacted her, admitting that such a string of bad luck with Hermes products was unprecedented.
Elena’s story is a powerful reminder that luxury brands, despite their image, can fall short in customer service. The treatment she received from Hermes highlights a critical issue: the disparity between the brand’s promises and its actual customer care practices.
Conclusion: The Importance of Speaking Out
Stories like Elena's are why Voice of Leatherverse is so important. It gives customers a platform to share their experiences and hold brands accountable. Whether you’ve had an exceptional or disappointing experience, your story matters. By sharing it, you contribute to a more transparent and equitable market where customers have a voice.
Luxury brands, just like any other, should be held to the standards they advertise. They should offer not only high-quality products but also exceptional customer service. When they fail to do so, it’s up to us, the customers, to speak out and demand better.
If you have a story to share, reach out. Let’s give the real bosses of the leather market—the customers—the platform they deserve. Together, we can help ensure that luxury brands deliver on their promises, creating a better experience for everyone in the Leatherverse.
Leave a comment